by niles » Sat Jun 25, 2005 2:25 am
dugawug, I had the same thoughts but although I like Kompakt, I think I'll keep the E4XT. A couple of days ago I bought translator- special edition NI. Well long story short, the translations into NI were not to good. Even tweeking them would not fix em. Not all but a good amount anyways. So I purchased cdxtract. Much better, so I've been comparing things for the last couple of days. I've got the Kontakt demo, and I set that plus Kompakt and the Emu up in Cubase for side by side compaisums. As far as the Emu being fatter sounding, I'm not buying it. It depends on the sample of course and with some translations that came off well and with a bit of tweeking, I really couldn't tell the difference either in Kompakt or Kontakt or the Emu. The major drawback is in the translations of sophisticated presets, samples, sounds. I'm no sample expert but these were terrible. I dont think salvagable at all. Maybe theres some special setting in translator I'm not getting and there are not many user settings in cdxtract so I may be off a bit there but I dont think so. I do like cdxtract. In the end, If you dig the Emu which is hard not to, then stick with it. Get Kompakt. I got an old version at GC for $100 and upgraded for free. Hard to beat that. From what I've read most like the library much more than Kontakts. Kontakt has alot more to offer in manipulation. If you can get a cheap version of Kompakt, theres a cheaper upgrade path to Kontakt. I'm sure alot of people hear will do their own sampling as far as the library thing goes. Thats where i'm at so far with all this if it makes any sense. Don't wanna see you regret selling.
niles