by madmax » Mon Aug 11, 2003 8:06 pm
OK there are exceptions to every rule - fo sho.
You can get a fabalus sound by combining 2 808 kicks a half step apart (which undoubtedly share harmonic overtones - the whole "wobble" of the sound comes from phase cancellation and addition). This would be an example of breaking that particular rule deliberatly to get sastisfying results constructivly. If you look down to the three choices a couple of paragraphs down, in this case A) would be a perfectly acceptable choice.
Anyone familiar with the additive and subtractive effects of sound waves will recognize how to manipulate in order to get the results he (or possibly she) wants. However ... as n00bs will enevitably use this ... it is important to underscore the separation of frequency when dealing with basses in particular.
Let's say that you have 2 bass sounds (we'll keep it simple)
One runs from about 20 Hz to 90 Hz, the other from 60 Hz to 20 kHz. The second one is overlapping the first. This will lead to 60 Hz to 90 Hz being overly represented in the sonic spectrum. The two sound waves will add (remember your trig lads) at those frequencies and create a spike (or worse - they could be out of phase which could lead to a big hole in the mix, innit). Now this spike will ensure that you must A) lower the volume of the bassline in general (this is not acceptable as you then will not be able to hear the frequencies that didn't get boosted by the phase addition (can I say that?)), B) the rest of your freqeuencies will not be able to reach their potential amplitude as this spike is forcing you to reduce the overall volume of your track, or C) highpass that biziatch up to 90 Hz.
The "correct" answer is C. (OK fuck it, if you want your toons to be pussy hurt than there is no "correct" answer)
Think of trying to get a lid on a box that has a square in it. If the square has a lump on one side, you can't get the lid on - you have to reduce the overall size of the square, which means that you end up with more room in the box that you can't use. Dilli's tracks sound so huge (if utterly boring - that's another topic) because he is able to cram sound up to the top. Remember, frequencies add. If you have no more room in that portion of the harmonic spectrum, adding more there will make the mix sound quieter and muddier.
OK that was a rather long winded answer but this is one of the main reasons that tracks don't sound loud enough. It's not something that I've been able to master either. EQings a bitch and IMO the hardest part of producing.
Hope this helps ...
Maxwell